homeschooling

Extracurricular Burnout: How to Tell When to Keep Going or Try Something New

In high school, I did theatre, band, and choir all at once, and I was a happy clam. I wanted more. (If somebody had offered me a fourth thing, I would have asked what time rehearsal started.)

Not every kid is built that way.

Some can handle one thing and then need a week on the floor with a blanket and a book. Some kids want to be in soccer and baseball and volleyball and need more!

That’s what makes extracurricular burnout so slippery for homeschool parents. The same calendar that fills one child up can drain another one dry. Even in the same family!

So how do you tell the difference between a kid who needs to push through a rough patch and a kid who needs permission to stop?

It’s hard to know when to go ahead and pull the plug on an extracurricular or when you need to motivate the kid not to give up! Especially when you’ve had them do the dance lessons or music lessons or whatever for several semesters and you don’t want to waste their skills. We all want to teach our kids to not be Give Up kinda people…

Here’s a way to sort it out, with a little research, a few of my own stories, and a short test you can run at the kitchen table.

Extracurricular Burnout Isn’t About the Number

My mom knew I was a high-energy kid, and she thoughtfully built parts of my childhood around it. She was a choir director, so I followed her to work. I hung out backstage at her other shows. I learned to run lights and sound. I felt at home in the wings, watching her put on shows. By high school, I needed every bit of artistic expression that could fit into a day.

Backstages are always a lot like the Muppet Theater – organized chaos, somebody always shouting about the schedule, and everyone weirdly happy about it. I love all the wires, mics, lights, everything. Sometimes my teachers sometimes fought over my time. (“No, band rehearsal comes first!”), but it always worked out.

If my mom had had a One Extracurricular rule, I would have been sad. Truly.

I’ve seen lots of articles about that insist that parents should choose only one activity and that would have made me super sad as a kid…

Now for the other side of the story. A 2024 study in Economics of Education Review, by economists at the University of Georgia and the Federal Reserve Board, analyzed time diaries from about 4,300 children, kindergarten through twelfth grade. They found that past a certain point, the last hour of homework and scheduled activities did nothing for test scores and made kids’ behavior and mood worse. The emotional costs showed up before academic skills had maxed out, and they were strongest in the high school years. Part of that is clearly too much homework, too, but too many activities can definitely be bad.

The researchers were careful about what they were saying. The activities themselves aren’t the villain. The total load is. And they couldn’t name a magic number of hours, because the right amount probably differs from kid to kid. One of the authors offered a simple gut check: ask whether your days are so full that there’s no room for a spontaneous playdate.

So the problem isn’t the number on the list. It’s whether the load fits the kid. I was fine at three major ones. Another child might be flattened at one.

Count what’s really on the calendar.

Here’s where homeschool parents undercount. A kid who does homeschool choir, violin lessons, worship band, and a second instrument doesn’t have one “music” commitment. That’s four things: four rehearsal or lesson schedules, four sets of practice, and four sets of driving.

The same goes for “theatre” (rehearsals, tech week, performances, costume fittings) and “co-op” (the class, the homework, the field day, the drive). Write each one down separately. Not to judge the total – just to see it.

Hard Day or the Wrong Fit? A Test You Can Use

Psychologist Angela Duckworth, who wrote Grit, runs what she calls the Hard Thing Rule in her family. In her book, she lays out three parts. Everyone, parents included, does something hard that takes daily practice. You get to pick your own hard thing. And you’re allowed to quit.

The catch is when. You don’t quit in the middle of a season or on a rough day. You finish what you committed to, and then you decide. One of her daughters cycled through about half a dozen hard things before one stuck.

That gives parents a useful dividing line. Quitting isn’t the problem. Quitting on a bad Tuesday is.

You don’t want to allow excuses to let a child waste their talents.

I haven’t read the book but heard good things. At any rate…

Before you decide anything, run through these questions:

  • Is it hard, or is it joyless? Struggle with visible progress is learning. Dread with no progress is a signal.
  • Did your child choose it? If you picked it, it’s your hard thing, not theirs.
  • What’s actually the problem? The activity, the teacher, the load, or the timing? Fix the right one.
  • Do they come home buzzing with energy or depleted? Watch over several weeks, not one bad day.
  • Is there a natural stopping point? Finish the season or semester, then decide together.

Sometimes the problem is the teacher. Let’s admit it.

My daughter loves art so I enrolled her in an art class that had great reviews from other parents. She tried it a few weeks, but I took her out.

The reason I took her out was because the teacher kept pushing her to create art exactly like the example instead of being herself. Her art was criticized repeatedly for not being cookie cutter! That’s the opposite of art. That’s also the opposite of how I raised her! It was hurting her spirit to hear that from an authority figure.

Teachers are human, and humans are fallible.

A good teacher can still be the wrong match for your family, and you’re allowed to say so.

Even if they don’t do something “wrong” per say, sometimes our personalities just don’t mesh and that’s ok.

Researchers who study why kids drop out of youth sports point the same direction: dropout is associated with a lack of enjoyment and with low self-determination, and the climate the adult creates matters a great deal. A coach or teacher who drains the joy out of the work is worth a hard look before you blame your child’s grit.

Homeschooling is supposed to be joyful and fun – take anything out of your life that makes is a slog.

Helping Kids Find What They Actually Love

Duckworth has said that people can’t become truly gritty at things they don’t love. So before you ask a kid to push through, make sure there’s something worth pushing toward. The first job is finding the thing.

Full disclosure: I am not sporty at all (not for lack of trying), so I can’t speak to sports from experience. But the best research on this question comes from youth sports, so that’s where I looked. Jean Côté’s widely used model describes a “sampling” stage, roughly ages 6 to 12, where kids try many activities. Specializing comes in the early teens, and deeper investment later. Reviews of that research link early sampling to more enjoyment, longer participation, and stronger inner motivation, and link very early specialization to a higher risk of burnout.

Two honest notes. First, every bit of the sampling and dropout research above comes from youth sports – not violin, choir, theatre, or other artistic pursuits, which is where my experience lies. I think the principles of variety, enjoyment, and choice travel well to the arts, but that is my read, not a proven finding. Second, sampling means kids will drop some things, and the models rarely say much about that part. Which is exactly why a parent’s judgment matters.

Another framework, Self-Determination Theory from psychologists Edward Deci and Richard Ryan, says healthy motivation rests on three needs: autonomy, competence, and relatedness. In homeschool terms:

  • Autonomy: your child gets a real say, including the right to veto.
  • Competence: they can feel themselves getting better.
  • Relatedness: they belong somewhere, and someone is glad when they show up.

Try things without signing a contract for the next five years!

Think of it as a menu, not a contract. A few low-stakes ways to sample:

  • Sit in on a rehearsal, a practice, or a trial class before you pay for anything.
  • Rent or borrow the instrument.
  • Set a one-semester trial with a clear finish line.
  • Offer three options instead of twenty.
  • Debrief at the end: What did you like? What would you change?

Know Your Kid’s Energy Style

I was a kid who got fuel from a full schedule. Plenty of kids are the opposite. Introverts and extroverts differ in how much outside stimulation they need to function well. Introverts tend to feel just right with less, and extroverts often draw energy from busy, social settings.

I’m an introvert at heart but I get my energy from art. Theatre situations generally end up being a lot of secretly introverted people enjoying being together inside their own mental bubbles, so it all works out in the end.

Psychologist Brian Little coined the term “restorative niche” for a place or activity where you recharge after being “on.” He also warns that acting out of character for long stretches can wear a person down. A University of Minnesota early childhood source adds a helpful caution: the energy binary is less simple than it sounds, and introverts often lean toward depth while extroverts lean toward breadth. So treat it as a lens, not a label.

What does that look like at home?

  • A kid who thrives on a full plate may need more rehearsals, not fewer. Even happy clams still need sleep.
  • A kid who needs downtime may do one activity well and then be done. That’s a normal kid, not a lazy one.
  • Every child, whatever their style, benefits from a quiet corner and some unscheduled time.

Here’s the check-in I’d use weekly, ideally on the way home or over dinner, some time with no pressure: “What gave you energy this week, and what drained you?” The answers will tell you more than any chart!

If you’d like a little paper help with that weekly question, I made a free printable called What Gave You Energy This Week? It’s a simple way to keep tabs on every activity on your calendar without relying on memory or one rough Tuesday. Subscribe to download it here, print a copy, and bring it along for the drive home. (The car is a very good place for this conversation. Nobody has to make eye contact.)


Download Your
What Gives You Energy
Printable Art!

​

Subscribe to download your freebie!

    We won’t send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.

    Permission to Keep Going, and Permission to Stop

    You’re not raising a quitter when you let a child leave the activity just isn’t a good personality fit after finishing the season. You’re also not a tyrant when you hold the line on a bad Tuesday and don’t let your kid throw away their dance shoes quite yet. The work is knowing your kid, and that changes year by year.

    If your calendar looks crowded this week, start with the tally. Write down every commitment separately, ask the energy question, and see what the numbers say. Then decide what to keep, what to trim, and what to try next.

    If you’d like more short, practical homeschool encouragement in your inbox, you can join the email list. And if you’d rather listen, the Homeschool with Joy podcast has quick episodes on topics just like this one.

    Subscribe to Homeschool with Joy and get free resources

    Get your free 15-page planner + a whole library of printables!

      We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at anytime.

      Leave a Reply